Preprint. Exploring research quality and journal representation: A comparative study of African Journals Online, Web of Science, and Scopus
This page includes information on a paper currently under review. Here you have access to the full text, materials and code.
Abstract
The unequal knowledge production and dissemination structure divide the world’s academic system into a dominating mainstream circuit and a peripherical one. Several local and international initiatives have recently emerged to reduce regional inequalities and build alternative transnational publishing circuits. This project studies alternative publishing circuits and their representation in international bibliometric databases. To do so, it focuses on the African publishing environment. Using Ulrich’s periodicals database, a regional journal platform (African Journals Online, AJOL hereafter), Scimago Journal Ranking (SJR), and Journal Citation Reports (JCR) data, this paper shows the coverage of the databases of African journals and their relative coverage in terms of countries and research areas. The results show that mainstream databases are biased toward specific countries and research areas, which has important social and academic implications. Building on the preliminary findings presented here, this work will be developed further by including additional variables, improving research area assignation, and considering analysis at the publication level.
Preprint
Access the preprint here
Data and materials
Data used fot the analysis is openly available here